Home » United States » Sale » New York » Bay Shore

19,844+ Pets for Sale in Bay Shore, New York | $100 – $2,900

Discover from over 19,844 available Pets currently listed for sale across Bay Shore, New York on PetzLover! We've added 1+ new listings this week, and you can explore diverse breeds like African Grey, American Pit Bull Terrier, Bichon Frise, Capuchins Monkey, Chinchilla, Corgi, Holland Lop, Lionhead rabbit, Mice, Old English Bulldog, Otter, Sugar Glider. Based on your current search criteria, you're viewing Pets with prices/fees ranging from $100 – $2,900. These include Pets typically 5 weeks – 2.0 years old, with approximately 8,270 males and 8,270 female available in Bay Shore, New York and surrounding areas. Find your perfect companion from trusted local breeders and reputable rescues, with many offering safe, convenient shipping or transportation options. Secure your perfect companion today!

Filters
Get Notified for New ListingsSubscribed
looking for good home 5 weeks old
$200
For Sale

looking for good home 5 weeks old

ve11io30+ days ago

american pit bull terrier looking for good home 5 weeks old you can call or text me at **..

American Pit Bull Terrier Puppy
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
4 month old Teddy Bear Bichon Shih-tzu
$1,500
For Sale

4 month old Teddy Bear Bichon Shih-tzu

Soniang6187630+ days ago

His name is Sparky, he is a teddy bear (Bichon Shih tzu) He’s 4 months, very friendly a..

Bichon Frise Puppy
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Friendly Corgi
$1,200
For Sale

Friendly Corgi

Sanamamartin30+ days ago

Cute lil corgi who is comforting and friendly to all. He gets along great with kids and o..

Corgi Puppy
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Olde English Bulldogge puppy
$1,800
For Sale

Olde English Bulldogge puppy

miguelvega122130+ days ago

8 weeks old full registration pedigree updated on vaccine contact ** ** **9 with more ..

Old English Bulldog Puppy
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Premium
DOODLE POODLE POM PUPPY
$2,000
For Sale

DOODLE POODLE POM PUPPY

Ally Baker

I have 4 other puppies available in the litter. 4 females and one male. Abbey is a small ..

Pomapoo Puppy
iTampa, Hillsborough County, FloridaTampa, Florida
See All Details
Premium
Mini Golden doodle -blizzard 💙
$2,500
For Sale

Mini Golden doodle -blizzard 💙

Lisa Pressley

“They are multigenerational which means both parents are Goldendoodles vs one parent be..

Golden Doodle Puppy
iVenus, Johnson County, TexasVenus, Texas
See All Details
Premium
Beautiful AKC Labrador Puppies – Black, Yellow & Chocolate
$895
For Sale

Beautiful AKC Labrador Puppies – Black, Yellow & Chocolate

VICTORIA CHAVEZ

We are excited to offer AKC-registered Labrador Retriever puppies available in Black, Yel..

Labrador Retriever Puppy
iLeland, Brunswick County, North CarolinaLeland, North Carolina
See All Details
Premium
Exotic kittens SH or LH
$1,800
For Sale

Exotic kittens SH or LH

Mercedescats

Beautiful litter born and ready for deposits. parents are CFA and TICA registered they co..

Exotic Shorthair Kitten
iPalm Coast, Flagler County, FloridaPalm Coast, Florida
See All Details
Talkative African grey 4 yrs old.
$500
For Sale

Talkative African grey 4 yrs old.

Fermbino30+ days ago

The African Gray comes with a cage. Only local pick up in New York...

African Grey Bird
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Sugar Gliders given away for free
For Sale

Sugar Gliders given away for free

mig11530+ days ago

I have two Sugar Gliders about 8 months old. I am given them away. One male is grey with ..

Sugar Glider
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Otter for sale
$1,500
For Sale

Otter for sale

dwellingexoticpetss30+ days ago

You can get adorable male and female otter for sale near me, they are all potty trained, ..

Otter
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
monkeys for sale under 1000
$2,900
For Sale

monkeys for sale under 1000

dwellingexoticpetss30+ days ago

we have adorable male and female Capuchin monkey for sale at very good prices. you can al..

Capuchins Monkey
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Premium
Persian Fluffy and adirable
$1,800
For Sale

Persian Fluffy and adirable

Mercedescats

I have this beautiful little girl that is a tabby that loves to be held. She will be read..

Persian Kitten
iPalm Coast, Flagler County, FloridaPalm Coast, Florida
See All Details
Pinky and the brain crew
$45
For Sale

Pinky and the brain crew

Karla30+ days ago

Group of 5I love them so much they are so funny and comfortable with human affection I ..

Mice
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Chinchilla
$325
For Sale

Chinchilla

jasminefuentes71730+ days ago

Violet/light gray friendly Chinchilla named Rocky, close to 2 years old. He is very comfo..

Chinchilla
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Lion head baby bunny for sale
$130
For Sale

Lion head baby bunny for sale

Kailaannex30+ days ago

Black and white lion head with blues eyes bunny for sale Very sweet loves to be held ..

Lionhead rabbit
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
2 female rabbits
$120
For Sale

2 female rabbits

Shantelstaggs30+ days ago

We are selling our two female rabbits due to moving. They are 3 months old one is black o..

Holland Lop Rabbit
iBay Shore, Islip, Suffolk County, New YorkIslip, New York
See All Details
Premium
Blue Pup 1
$1,899
For Adoption

Blue Pup 1

RENEE LONGO

They are from Champion bloodlines.They will be extra large. With proper care they will be..

Great Dane Puppy
iWoodbridge, South Central Connecticut Planning Region, ConnecticutWoodbridge, Connecticut
See All Details
Premium
CFA Exotic Shorthair, Chocolate Tortie
$2,300
For Sale

CFA Exotic Shorthair, Chocolate Tortie

Nik8201

Reese is the total package... She adores children and get along with everyone! She is swe..

Exotic Shorthair Kitten
iLexington, Fayette County, KentuckyLexington, Kentucky
See All Details
Premium
Brussels griffon girl.
$1,000
For Rehoming

Brussels griffon girl.

Jodi Saunders

Sweet gabby girl is a beautiful brussels griffon with a wirecoat whimsical look. She is l..

Brussels Griffon Puppy
iNew Smyrna Beach, Volusia County, FloridaNew Smyrna Beach, Florida
See All Details
Premium
BROOKS - Willie - 2025
$2,200
For Sale

BROOKS - Willie - 2025

Angie Hoefs

Very loving, They love to be held have a great personalities and very attentive. Get alon..

Scottish Terrier Puppy
iBrooksville, Hernando County, FloridaBrooksville, Florida
See All Details
Premium
Maximum Birds Available for Sale https://***/
$1,000
For Sale

Maximum Birds Available for Sale https://***/

Maxwell Ezra

Please visit our website if you want to get more info on the birds https://**..

Blue-and-yellow Macaw Bird
iManhattan, New York, New York County, New YorkNew York, New York
See All Details
Premium
Star - panda male GSD
$3,000
For Sale

Star - panda male GSD

Pam Sutherland

Star is a fun, loving, little pup. He has amazing blue eyes. He is crate trained and begs..

German Shepherd Puppy
iMonroe, Monroe, Orange County, New YorkMonroe, New York
See All Details
Premium
Maine coon sweet kittens
$2,150
For Sale

Maine coon sweet kittens

luba Si

European Maine Coon kittens is looking for a loving home. Raised at home with plenty of ..

Maine Coon Kitten
iBrooklyn, Kings County, New YorkBrooklyn, New York
See All Details

Explore More Pets